Experts Warn We Must Act Now to Protect Human Creativity
Professor Giovanni Emanuele Corazza and colleagues from the International Society for the Study of Creativity and Innovation set out a decalogue of research challenges for cyber-creativity, from theory and education to ethics.
Read the original paper
People are increasingly wondering what creativity means now that generative artificial intelligence is becoming a part of everyday life. With smart technologies rapidly entering creative spaces like art, writing, and music, a group of experts from the International Society for the Study of Creativity and Innovation (ISSCI) joined forces to explore how humans and machines can work together creatively. Led by Professor Giovanni Emanuele Corazza from the University of Bologna, the team laid out ten major domains that need attention to better understand what they call “cyber-creativity,” covering all possible forms of collaboration between humans and machines in creativity. Their findings were published in the peer-reviewed Journal of Intelligence, offering a timely roadmap for a world where machines are becoming artificial artists, co-authors, and creative partners.
Scholars involved in this study come from many countries and backgrounds, bringing different viewpoints to the conversation. To underline the fact that humanity is at a crossroads, they described two starkly different futures for creativity in the age of AI. One is a utopian future where AI helps people express themselves in unprecedented ways and with real-time responsiveness, a world where technology helps people connect with their feelings, personalize their education, and protect their creative rights. The other is a dystopian future where AI-generated content floods society, and creative jobs and ideas become controlled by machines and large companies. It’s a stark warning, where AI tools produce vast amounts of content with little soul, leaving human artists feeling left out and powerless. The study presents these two extremes to urge society to focus on better choices and avoid harmful paths.
Thinking about creativity today requires a broader perspective. The group suggests that creativity isn’t just something that belongs to humans; rather, it is a phenomenon that spans four interconnected layers: material, such as tools and media; biological, referring to the brain and body; psycho-social, covering thoughts, emotions, and group dynamics; and artificial, introducing digital systems and intelligent machines. As AI tools and agents become more advanced, they have a legitimate role in the creative process, hopefully not replacing humans, but working alongside them. These new tools can support and interact with people in making art, solving problems, or inventing new ideas. The team refers to any joint work between people and smart machines as cyber-creativity, a term that describes a continuum from purely human to purely artificial creativity. They encourage others to study this growing area more closely, forecasting that it might evolve into a discipline of its own.
“Surprisingly, Gen-AI has demonstrated creative capacities that apparently nearly match the level of professional human creatives on specific tasks,” said Professor Corazza, noting both the promise and the unease surrounding how powerful these tools have become. Gen-AI, short for generative artificial intelligence, refers to systems like ChatGPT or multi-modal generating tools that can produce text, images, music, or video on their own based on patterns learned from data. His comments point to the need for balance, using AI to support human imagination without taking it over.
Seeing how quickly AI is changing the way people create, the team emphasizes the need to rethink how we understand, manage, and guide creativity in this new era. To that end, they identified a decalogue, ten essential research areas that span from the theoretical roots of cyber-creativity to how humans and machines collaborate, and to the broader cultural and ethical impacts. These include understanding the foundational ideas that guide human–AI creativity; the cultural and social environments in which it develops; and the shifting roles and identities of both human and artificial creators. The researchers also explore how collaborative work unfolds within hybrid teams, how audiences react to AI-assisted content, and how creative professions are adapting to these technologies. Finally, the decalogue highlights the need to rethink creative education, address ethical challenges such as fairness and transparency, and consider the darker possibilities, where creative tools might be misused for manipulation or harm. The team calls for collaboration across fields—technology, psychology, design, education, philosophy—to ensure this transformation benefits humanity as a whole.
Turning attention to the next steps, the team outlines key questions that researchers need to explore. These range from how AI changes the way people see themselves as creative thinkers, to how schools and universities should teach creativity now, and even how teams can function when some members are machines. They also raise concerns about fairness, bias, meaning built-in preferences or exclusions in AI behavior due to the data it learns from, and the importance of being honest about where creative content comes from. These questions are not abstract; they affect the future of learning, identity, and meaningful work.
“Whereas AI holds the promise of increased efficiency in the creative process, we must ensure this does not come at the expense of the quality and authenticity of creative outcomes,” Professor Corazza explained. Authenticity here refers to whether creative work expresses a personal, cultural, or emotional truth, something more than just novelty or usefulness. This statement captures the heart of the research, ensuring that as technology advances, it continues to protect and amplify what makes creativity deeply human.
Setting the stage for the future, Professor Corazza and the ISSCI team call for action. They want researchers, educators, decision-makers, and the public to work together in shaping how creativity and technology will interact. If this collaboration succeeds, the result could be a future where both humans and machines contribute to creative work in a way that keeps the human spirit at the heart of creation.
About the researchers
Journal reference
Corazza, G. E., Agnoli, S., Jorge Artigau, A., Beghetto, R. A., Bonnardel, N., Coletto, I., Faiella, A., Gerardini, K., Gilhooly, K., Glăveanu, V. P., Hanson, M. H., Kapoor, H., Kaufman, J. C., Kenett, Y. N., Kharkhurin, A. V., Luchini, S., Mangion, M., Mirabile, M., Obialo, F.-K., Phelps, C., Reiter-Palmon, R., Puryear, J. S., Sarcinella, E. D., Tang, M., Vavassori, M. G., Vinchon, F., Viskontas, I., Weiss, S., Zbainos, D., Lubart, T. (2025). “Cyber-Creativity: A Decalogue of Research Challenges.” Journal of Intelligence, 13(8): 103. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/jintelligence13080103































