Rigorous research methods for ethical issues in mental healthcare: Reducing the use of coercion
Professor Tilman Steinert's team found that helping German psychiatric wards follow guidelines on preventing coercion improved adherence but did not significantly reduce how often coercive measures were used.
Read the original paper
The ethical quandary of employing force or restraint in mental health care encapsulates a profound societal challenge: how to balance the imperative for humane treatment with the necessity of care. This tension between protecting individual rights and ensuring the well-being of patients and caregivers fuels a vigorous debate and underscores the critical demand for innovative approaches in psychiatric interventions. These approaches must champion dignity and compassion at their core. As we explore this critical issue, it becomes evident that there are concerted efforts underway to transform psychiatric care, illuminating the nuanced interplay between ethical principles and the practicalities of providing mental health treatment.
In an effort to refine psychiatric care practices, a significant study detailed in The Lancet Regional Health – Europe and led by Professor Tilman Steinert from Ulm University, set out to examine the implementation of guidelines designed to mitigate the use of coercive measures in 55 psychiatric in-patient units across Germany. This ambitious research initiative stood out for its comprehensive approach and the employment of external consultants to facilitate guideline implementation, resulting in nuanced findings that enrich our understanding of clinical practices in psychiatric care.
Reflecting on the study’s objectives, Professor Steinert shared, “The major result of the PreVCo study was that we could not show that the intervention aiming at improving guideline adherence had a significant impact on the primary outcome measure, the frequency of coercive measures used in the participating wards.” However, the main reason for this negative finding was that the median number of coercive measures used decreased by 45 % from baseline until the end of the intervention period on the intervention wards, but also by 28 % on waiting list wards. This was probably due to observer effects, while in the same time, during the COVID-19 pandemic, the use of coercion increased in psychiatric hospitals in Germany. Despite the challenging goal of reducing coercive measures, the study marked significant strides in other areas of psychiatric care practices.
A noteworthy success of the research was the marked improvement in guideline adherence among the intervention wards, as measured by the PreVCo Rating Tool. “Team performance in terms of guideline implementation was significantly better in the intervention group after a year,” Professor Steinert observed. This outcome signals a positive shift towards structured interventions and showcases the potential of external consultants in driving such transformative changes in clinical practices.
This study also stands as a testament to the ongoing journey towards more ethical, patient-centered psychiatric care. The insights gleaned from this research provide a solid foundation for future explorations, emphasizing the necessity of continuous innovation in the quest to minimize coercion in psychiatric care. Professor Steinert aptly concludes, “Further research from adequately powered robust RCTs is necessary to identify effective interventions to reduce the use of coercion in psychiatric hospitals.” This call to action underscores the commitment to advancing patient care and upholding the dignity and rights of individuals in psychiatric settings. Overall, the research led by Professor Tilman Steinert and his team, while navigating the complexities of implementing change within psychiatric care practices, contributes valuable insights into the efforts to reduce coercion. Its findings and the advancements in guideline adherence serve as a beacon for future research, paving the way for further improvements in psychiatric care that respect the rights and dignity of all patients.
About the researchers
Journal reference
Steinert, T., et al. (2023). “Implementation of guidelines on prevention of coercion and violence (PreVCo) in psychiatry: a multicentre randomised controlled trial.” The Lancet Regional Health – Europe, 35, 100770. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.lanepe.2023.100770




